The many sides to the dilemma of whether or not euthanasia should be carried out

It has also clearly stated that a person attempts suicide in a depression, and hence he needs help, rather than punishment.

The many sides to the dilemma of whether or not euthanasia should be carried out

Those in favour of eugenics go further, and say that society should prevent 'defective' people from having children. The fear is that if euthanasia is allowed, vulnerable people will be put under pressure to end their lives. The practice of palliative care counters this view, as palliative care would provide relief from distressing symptoms and pain, and support to the patient as well as the care giver. While as Christians we would say our bodies are not our own, legally, a man is free to end his life when he chooses. I will then consider arguments for and against euthanasia, before giving a Christian perspective. Last year a bill was tabled in the Federal Senate trying to reactivate it. This suggests that doctors have stereotypes of who is not worth saving Top Pressure on the vulnerable This is another of those arguments that says that euthanasia should not be allowed because it will be abused. This week, the House of Lords debated a select committee report on Lord Joffe's Assisted Dying for the Terminally Ill bill, an earlier version of the peer's forthcoming proposal. In: Begshawe KD, editor.

That is, that we do not kill each other, even for reasons of mercy and compassion. Med Law Rev, 7 2 : — Even if we accept that large numbers of people would like the option to request euthanasia though, the proportion of people actually requesting it when facing death is very different.

religious arguments against euthanasia

Another doctor will review medical records and talk with the patient. Psychol Addict Behav. But providing palliative care can be very hard work, both physically and psychologically.

quotes against euthanasia

The term is derived from the Greek word euthanatos which means easy death. There are serious discussions going on in Montana, Singapore and Spain.

euthanasia essay pdf

So making euthanasia easier could exacerbate the slippery slope, pushing people towards euthanasia who may not otherwise choose it. The disabled person's perspective Part of the problem is that able-bodied people look at things from their own perspective and see life with a disability as a disaster, filled with suffering and frustration.

The Judgment laid down is to preserve harmony within a society, when faced with a complex medical, social and legal dilemma.

Euthanasia debate

In the Northern Territory passed legislation allowing euthanasia, but it was overturned by the Federal Parliament in Once again this will be done carefully in consultation with the patient and their family and we will seek to preserve the dignity of the patient. The objective is to discuss the subject of euthanasia from the medical and human rights perspective given the background of the recent Supreme Court judgement 3 in this context. White H Right to die: Many patients in a persistent vegetative state or else in chronic illness, do not want to be a burden on their family members. She was put on a ventilator. So making euthanasia easier could exacerbate the slippery slope, pushing people towards euthanasia who may not otherwise choose it. Bypassing the countries that privilege euthanasia as less serious murder, in this paper we have dealt with some legislations that this phenomenon strictly prohibit, and those that deprivation of life out of compassion treat as a permitted medical procedure. I believe western medicine has progressed as far as it has because we do value all human lives and continue to seek cures for the diseases which afflict us. I prefer to keep the definition narrow, so we can evaluate each end of life scenario individually. Ending a patient's life by injection is quicker and easier and cheaper. He very quickly realized that he had been hooked up to the one thing he feared the most. Nevertheless, the practice still generates plenty of robust opposition. While acknowledging that life on a ventilator is certainly not a walk in the park, Oda now realizes he misunderstood what it would be like.

Till date, most of the States has not done anything to support the terminally ill people by providing for hospice care.

In fact, after the euthanasia doctor has an obligation to fill out the appropriate protocol and inform about euthanasia the municipal pathologist, by filling out the appropriate form and attaching all necessary documents

Arguments for euthanasia essay

While the select committee was able to agree that in the interests of the wider community some limits should be set on patients' autonomy, it could reach no consensus on where those limits should be. While students now receive training in pain control, there are many doctors in the community who are not aware of what can be done. In cases where the patient was not able on his own to administer the lethal dose, a doctor or nurse would be permitted to do so. I prefer to keep the definition narrow, so we can evaluate each end of life scenario individually. What do we have to say to those who suffer? They say that most of these problems can be identified by assessing the patient properly, and, if necessary, the system should discriminate against the opinions of people who are particularly vulnerable. For these reasons, the Belgian legislator issued detailed provisions, in order to provide a greater level of protection and security to doctors and patients Motivation prompts us to act but does not inform the content of our actions, so common motivation may lead to different actions. In such situations, palliative and rehabilitative care comes to the rescue of the patient and the family. He is in agony. So making euthanasia easier could exacerbate the slippery slope, pushing people towards euthanasia who may not otherwise choose it. Euthanasia is going to be ethically appropriate for some individuals whose morality recognizes autonomy as a priority.
Rated 6/10 based on 77 review
Download
Euthanasia: Right to life vs right to die